An Independence Day Tribute

 

            Each year on July 4th, I take some time away from cookouts, fireworks, and my family to spend a few moments with my favorite firearm. I sit alone in my gunroom, reflecting upon the one piece in my collection that for me most embodies Independence Day.  It doesn’t have a gas cylinder and isn’t Parkerized. It isn’t even a mint, perfect example; in fact it is probably the worst condition piece in my collection. It is a musket from the American War of Independence, a well-used Model 1763 Charleville flintlock musket that features a branded U STATES surcharge and three sets of initials carved into the stock. Both sling swivels have been removed and their studs filed nearly flush. You can’t even cock it due to a broken spring or worn sear. It is beat up and ugly; but I cherish this old musket. When I hold it I wonder about the three men whose initials give this musket some of its character. Were any of them members of the Continental Army? If so, in what battles did they carry this old musket? To what hardships were these men subjected? I will never know the answers to these questions, but I believe that this old musket was used to gain our independence and forge our liberties. Without men like the three who may have carried this Charleville into battle, there would be no Independence Day celebration with cookouts and fireworks; nor would there be a United States of America.

 

M1763 Charleville

            The French Model 1763 Infantry Musket was the military firearm most widely used by the Continental Army in the American Revolution. The Model 1763 was state-of-the-art for the day. It was a smoothbore musket of .69 caliber, featured flintlock ignition, was slightly over 60 inches long and weighed nearly nine pounds. Students of the period believe that over 100,000 flintlock military muskets of various models were obtained from France during our Revolution. The Model 1763 pattern arm was produced at three French National Armories: Charleville, Maubeuge, and St. Etienne. Collectors refer to all, regardless of location of manufacturer, as Charlevilles. The Charleville was later used as the pattern for the first U.S. Armory produced weapon, the Model of 1795.

 

 

Scott Duff with Model 1763 Charleville Musket

 

My Old Musket

            My Model 1763 was produced at the St. Etienne Armory, in the 1760s. The first photograph of my old musket was taken in my shop and shows the overall weapon with bayonet affixed. Noted American Revolution historian and author, George Neumann, has examined this bayonet and believes it to be of American manufacture in the 1750s to 1775 time frame. The other two photographs depict the lock and the brand applied U STATES surcharge.

 

 

Model 1763 Charleville Lock

 

Model 1763 Charleville Surcharge

 

 

During the American Revolution, the theft of continental muskets became a serious problem. When a soldier’s enlistment expired he went home, often taking his musket with him. If this habit were permitted to continue, the Army would soon be without a sufficient quantity of arms with which to continue the War. On February 4, 1777, the Board of War recommended to Congress that all continental arms be stamped with "United States." On February 24th, the Continental Congress resolved: "The arms and accoutrements, belonging to the United States, shall be stamped with the words ‘United States’, all arms already made to be stamped on such parts as will receive the impressions, and those hereinafter to be manufactured, to be stamped with the said words on every part comprising a stand."

            General Washington implemented this resolution on March 31, 1777, directing Colonel Benjamin Flower of the Commissary General’s Department to have all arms so stamped. On April 18, Washington issued a general order from his headquarters in Morristown, New Jersey, that all arms in stores and in the hands of troops be marked immediately.

            It is uncertain how rapidly his order was carried out. However, a U STATES brand is listed in the March 21, 1778 inventory of James Pearson, one of the commissaries of military stores. Historians of Revolutionary War arms agree that the earliest surcharge consisted of UNITED STATES branded into the stocks, or the contraction U. STATES or U STATES. It is believed that these variations date from 1777 through 1780. It is also believed that in late 1780, the surcharge was further contracted to US. This abbreviated surcharge is most often found struck on the metal components rather than on the stock. The US surcharge remained in use following the end the Revolution and throughout the Federal period.

 

John MacIlduff

My great, great, great, great, Grandfather, John MacIlduff, was of Scots-Irish decent and immigrated to America from Belfast, Northern Ireland in the early 1770s. He fought in the American Revolution, not in well-known battles fought along the eastern seaboard, but in skirmishes with Indians whom the British had induced to attack settlers on the western side of the Appalachian Mountains. He served as a private in Captain Thomas Morton’s Company of Westmoreland County Frontier Rangers between 1778 and 1783. It is unlikely that these Rangers were armed with military muskets such as the Model 1763. It is more probable that their weapons consisted of a variety of personal rifles or smoothbore hunting guns, as well as tomahawk and knife.

If you have visited my shop, you have driven past the cemetery in which John MacIlduff (1744-1816) and his wife, Ann Wallace Duff (1750-1831), are buried. Although the ravages of time and acid rains have taken their toll, their names remain visible on the hand-hewn tombstones. A flag with bronze marker denoting a veteran of the Revolutionary War is placed on his grave each Memorial Day. Furthermore, the land on which our house is built was a part of his original homestead dating from the early 1770s. His cabin was within a quarter of a mile of our home. In the 1960s my Grandfather tilled a garden in the field at the foot of the hill below where our parking area is today. In his garden we children found a number of Indian arrowheads. I have kept all that I found for these 40 plus years. If you visit my shop, ask and I will be happy to show you the arrowheads, as well as my old musket.

 

John McIlduff's grave with flag and marker

 

I fly the American flag at the top of a 20-foot flag pole, lighted by a dusk-to-dawn light, 365 days a year to commemorate all of those who endured hardships and gave their very lives in the fight for our independence and also in honor and rememberence to all, past and present, who have served in the armed forces in order to maintain the liberties we hold so dear.

Men like MacIlduff, my father J. Arthur Duff, Jr., and my father-in law Thomas Shoen, Jr. have been my inspiration to collect U.S. martial arms. They are not "just guns." The firearms in my collection, and those in yours, are what were used to win and preserve the liberties that we continue to enjoy today. Every U.S. martial arm and each man who carried them have a unique story to tell. But the result of each story is the same: Liberty!

J. Arthur Duff, Jr. (1929-1999) USMC and Thomas Shoen, Jr. (1924-2000) USA 11th Airborne Division

J. Arthur Duff, Jr. Thomas Shoen, Jr.

 

God Bless America!

Have a happy and thought filled Independence Day!